A Year in TV Guide: February 20th, 1965

A Year in TV Guide explores the 1964-1965 television season through the pages of TV Guide magazine. Each week, I’ll examine the issue of TV Guide published exactly 50 years earlier. The intent is not simply to examine what was on television each week but rather what was being written about television.

Week #23
February 20th, 1965
Vol. 13, No. 8, Issue #621
Western New England Edition

On the Cover: Burgess Meredith and James Franciscus of Mr. Novak (photograph by Larry Schiller).

The Magazine

There are a good mix of articles in this week’s issue. “No ‘Loxes’ Need Apply” is a three-page look at how Goodson-Todman Productions selects celebrity panelists for its various game shows like What’s My Line and To Tell the Truth, among others. It’s not easy. Every week potential players are packed around a conference table and rapidly run through various games while producers watch and take notes. Celebrities must meet three criteria: 1) have lively, attractive personalities; 2) be able to ad-lib entertainingly; and 3) be able to play at least one of the Goodson-Todman game shows well.

Front Cover
Front Cover – Copyright 1965 Triangle Publications, Inc.

The selection process is so rigorous, in fact, that getting just one good person out of 20 is considered good. As Mark Goodson explains, there are a lot of loxes, aka deadheads. Barbara Feldon and Kaye Ballard are given as two examples of non-loxes. Finding someone like that makes the producers feel great. Of course, exceptions are made for really big celebrities. If someone like Elizabeth Taylor wants to be on What’s My Line, the article notes, she’ll be invited no matter what.

John Maynard’s “All the World’s a Stage” discusses how many actors need to hold down other jobs in order to make ends meet. Allen Jenkins, for example, despite appearing in more than 230 movies over the course of three decades (plus a hundred TV shows), works as a car salesman in Santa Monica. According to the Screen Actors Guild, 90% of actors don’t make a living from acting alone. Of the 15,000 actors in the Guild, 65% make les than $5,000 a year and in fact average around $1,8000. Only 10% or 1,650 made more than $10,000 in 1963.

Other examples of moonlighting actors in the article include Billy Halop, who works at Ted’s Grill in Malibu; Leon Lontoc, who is a barber and maitre’d; Michael Wilding, who is a theatrical agent; Lola Albright, who owns restaurants; Vincent Price, who buys paintings for Sears; and Theodore Bikel, who owns part of a recording company. Hal Gerard went back to dentistry after years of acting, and makes more than $100,000 a year, so he can take acting jobs when it suits him. Even Jim Garner and Fred Astaire have side jobs: Garner is an officer of the Silver Lake National Bank in Los Angeles and Astaire owns a chain of dancing schools.

Geraldine Brooks is the actress being found in “To Find an Actress,” another TV Guide biographical sketch. Brooks is married to Budd Schulberg, author of the novel What Makes Sammy Run? who also wrote the screenplay to On the Waterfront. He penned her official biography as well. She spent her childhood talking to inanimate objects which came in handy when she took acting classes. “When they told me to be a tree and to imagine the sap running through me,” she explains, “I could do it because that is what I had been doing all my life.” Her family owns the Brooks Costume Company, which is where she got her stage name. She spent time in Italy making movies after failing to hit it big in Hollywood and is now happily married and content to take occasional film and TV roles. She would, however, like the chance to do comedy.

The most interesting article in this issue, at least for someone like me eager for behind-the-scenes information, is “Adding Curry to the Curriculum” by Dwight Whitney. It’s an in-depth look at how Burgess Meredith came to replace Dean Jagger on NBC’s Mr. Novak. This is the sort of article I love because it provides a lot of detail.

According to Whitney, the whole thing came down to a matter of ifs. If Jagger hadn’t started having concerns about the direction of the series and if he hadn’t put off an operation to treat a serious ulcer and if his doctor hadn’t issued an ultimatum on December 4th, 1964, his character Albert Vane would still be principal of Jefferson High School.

Likewise, if Meredith’s play I Was Dancing hadn’t closed a week before Jagger’s departure and if he hadn’t been in Hollywood right when Jagger left and if he hadn’t passed on a role on Wagon Train in order to do a two-part guest appearance on Mr. Novak, his character Martin Woodridge wouldn’t have become a series regular.

The two-part “Faculty Follies” was being filmed when Jagger announced he was leaving Mr. Novak (the script was actually written for another actor, Donald Pleasence, but he wasn’t available so Meredith was signed). Producer Leonard Freeman immediately thought of replacing Jagger with Meredith and approached executive producer E. Jack Neuman and MGM executive Alan Courtney. Both assumed Meredith would say no. After taking a weekend to think about it he surprised them all by agreeing.

An episode called “The Crowd Pleaser” in which Principal Vane ran for superintendent but lost had been filmed earlier in the season but shelved due to Freeman worrying viewers were sick of politics. The end was reworked, with Jagger performing via telephone, so that Vane won the election and appointed Woodridge the new principal. The episode was retitled “Mountains to Climb” and scheduled to air February 23rd.

Presumably, somewhere there exists the alternate version of the episode with the original ending. If Mr. Novak is ever released on DVD perhaps it will be included.

The “As We See It” editorial is all about Profiles in Courage this week and the news that NBC does not plan on repeating the critically acclaimed series during the summer. The final episode will air May 9th. However, the series will be syndicated. TV Guide wonders if it failed in the ratings because the second half-hour aired opposite Lassie on CBS, forcing NBC to find a replacement. “This is unfortunate for the roughly 12 million viewer who enjoy the program,” said TV Guide, “but is perfectly understandable. NBC is a business. And it has, at least made an effort.” The editorial ends by calling Profiles in Courage “a victim of the peculiar American commercial system that carefully excludes any but the most frivolous of programs (with mighty few exceptions) from winning a regular position on nighttime schedules.”

There is once again no review this week. Cleveland Amory is still judging the International Television Festival in Monaco. According to the January 30th issue, Amory’s reviews will return in March.

News from the Hollywood and New York TV Teletype columns:

  • NBC will likely cancel Kentucky Jones, The Rogues, Hazel, The Famous Adventures of Mr. Magoo, Karen, and That Was the Week That Was.
  • New shows planned for NBC include a weekly musical/variety hour starring Dean Martin, a spy drama called I Spy with Robert Culp and Bill Cosby, and Convoy with John Gvin.
  • ABC will premiere a new daytime game show in April called Rebus in which contestants will try to identify famous people using only sketches. [The Rebus Game debuted on March 29th and ran through September.]
  • Marlo Thomas, Ron Husmann, and Anne Jeffreys are starring in a comedy pilot called “Two’s Company,” a co-production between Universal, ABC, and Betford (Tennessee Ernie Ford’s production company). [It didn’t sell.]
  • Peter Falk will star in a comedy-drama series for CBS called O’Brien. He’ll play a lawyer. [The Trials of O’Brien ran for 22 episodes during the 1965-1966 season.]
  • Bob Hope might put together another special using footage from his last overseas tour.
  • Charmian Carr and Van Johnson will star in a comedy pilot based on the movie Take Her, She’s Mine for 20th Century-Fox. [It didn’t sell.]
  • Dick Clark is producing a musical special for CBS called “Where the Action Is” that might become a weekly series. [It did. The series ran from June 1965 to March 1967.]

Rounding out the national section this week is a picture feature examining the ghastly decor of The Addams Family house. It’s not a great picture feature because there are only two pictures and an awful lot of text from Leslie Raddatz. There is also the regular TV crossword puzzle.

There were three news reports in the “For the Record” column in the listings section this week:

  • The 1964-1965 television season has reached its midway point. Based on Nielsen ratings for the two weeks ending January 24th, here’s a look at the Top 10 and Bottom 10 programs:

    Top Ten:
    1. Bob Hope’s Christmas Show
    2. Bonanza
    3. “The Wizard of Oz”
    4. Bewitched
    5. The Andy Griffith Show
    6. The Ed Sullivan Show
    7. The Dick Van Dyke Show
    8. The Red Skelton Show
    9. The Fugitive
    10. Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C.

    Bottom 10:
    • The Bell Telephone Hour
    • On Broadway Tonight
    • That Was the Week That Was
    • The Joey Bishop Show
    • Mickey (cancelled)
    • Wagon Train
    • The Outer Limits (cancelled)
    • Kraft Suspense Theatre
    • Karen
    • The Baileys of Balboa
  • The networks have started planning their 1965 fall schedules which means cancellations are on their way. Returning shows in danger of getting the axe include Perry Mason, The Defenders, Rawhide, The Doctors and the Nurses, Mr. Novak, International Showtime, The Alfred Hitchcock Hour, The Jack Benny Program, Burke’s Law and The Jimmy Dean Show. New shows rumored to be in danger include Wendy and Me, The Bing Crosby Show, ABC Scope, Jonny Quest, Valentine’s Day, Kentucky Jones, Mr. Magoo, The Rogues, Slattery’s People, The Entertainers, The Cara Williams Show, Many Happy Returns, My Living Doll, and For the People. Some may return but most will be gone.
  • NBC is considering splitting Dr. Kildare in two and airing it twice a week during the 1965-1966 season. Unlike Peyton Place, however, it will not be serialized. Each episode will be standalone. [Dr. Kildare did air twice a week during the 1965-1966 season. Episodes were serialized to some degree, with storylines lasting a handful of episodes.]

The letters page was an interesting mix this week. Richard Rodgers wrote in to apologize for leaving conductor John Green out of his essay about “Cinderella” that was published in the January 23rd issue. There were two letters from readers angry that Jackie Gleason had called Plato “one of the stupidest men in the world” in a February 6th article. And two readers wrote in to praise Marya Mannes and her theoretical television network, which she wrote about in the February 6th issue. Then there was this lengthy letter:

To the Female start of Broadside: In the Jan. 9 article “Kathy Nolan of Broadside” you are quoted as saying, “Broadside involves serious actors and actresses doing comedy. McHale is a bunch of stand-up comics. We’re doing a job. They’re a bunch of goof-ups.” If you were quoted correctly,and inasmuch as we have all been subjects of TV Guide pieces, we have o reason to believe that you were not, may we say the following: Mr. Joe Flynn studied speech and drama at the University of Notre Dame and has a degree in the same field from the University of Southern California. Mr. Tim Conway has the same degree from Bowling Green State University. Mr. Ernest Borgnine has an Oscar signifying him to be the most outstanding dramatic actor of the year. Be that as it may, no matter what our academic or professional qualifications might be, we feel that inasmuch as we blazed a path in a field in which you are a pale copy, we are not deserving of your gratuitous insult.
McHale’s Navy
Universal City, Cal.

Wow. I must not have read the January 9th article about Kathy Nolan as closely as the cast of McHale’s Navy.

The TV Listings

The weekend was filled with sports, as always, with bowling, track and field, golf, horse racing, roller derby, basketball, and skating. NBC aired the third installment of Big Three Golf from 5-6PM on Saturday, February 20th while ABC broadcast Shell’s World of Golf from 4-5PM on Sunday, February 21st. Later that night, NBC rebroadcast “Return to Oz,” an hour-long color special that first aired on February 9th, 1964. General Electric took out a special three-page advertisement in the national section as well as an additional page in the listings section promoting its products and free gifts available in select stores. CBS aired its new version of “Rogers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella” on Monday, February 22nd from 8:30-10PM. Lesley Ann Warren starred as Cinderella with Stuart Damon as the prince, Ginger Rogers as the queen, Walter Pidgeon as the king, and Celeste Holm as the fairy godmother.

On Tuesday, February 23rd from 10-11PM, NBC aired a documentary called “The Journals of Lewis and Clark” produced and directed by Ted Yates. Lorne Greene narrated. ABC broadcast the first installment of Saga of Western Man for the season (“I, Leonardo da Vinci”) during the same time slot. On Friday, February 26th from 7:30-8:30PM, NBC repeated “The Restless Sea,” part of the Bell Science Series. The color special first aired on January 24th, 1964. Here’s a full page advertisement:

Advertisement for The Restless Sea on NBC
Advertisement for The Restless Sea on NBC – Copyright 1965 Triangle Publications, Inc.

Also on Friday, ABC aired “Inger Stevens in Sweden” from 8-9PM. The hour-long special saw Stevens touring Sweden, visiting the Royal Palace, talking with Prime Minister Tage Erlander, talking with boxer Ingermar Johansson, actor Max Von Sydow, and returning to her childhood home. An article about the special appeared in the January 30th issue.

Here are the TV Guide close-ups for the week:

  • Special: National Indoor Tennis Championship (WBZ-TV/WNHC-TV, Sunday at 2:00PM)
  • Shell’s World of Golf (ABC, Sunday at 4:00PM)
  • Special: Return to Oz (NBC, Sunday at 5:30PM)
  • Special: Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella (CBS, Monday at 8:30PM)
  • Bell Science Series – “The Restless Sea” (NBC, Friday at 7:30PM)
  • Special: Inger Stevens in Sweden (ABC, Friday at 8:00PM)

Here are some of the programs available for purchase by subscribers to Zenith Radio Company’s Phonevision pay television experiment on Connecticut’s WHCT-TV (Channel 18):

  • Movie: The Dream Maker (Saturday at 1PM, $0.50)
  • Movie: A Hard Day’s Night (Saturday at 7PM, $1.25)
  • Pro Hockey: Montreal Canadiens vs. New York Rangers (Live, Sunday at 7:30PM, $1.25)
  • Play: Sponono (Monday at 9PM, $1.50)
  • Movie: Goodbye Charlie (Tuesday at 8:30PM, $1.25)
  • Movie: Sex and the Single Girl (Wednesday at 8:30PM, $1.25)
  • Movie: First Men in the Moon (Thursday at 7PM, $1.25)
  • Movie: The Pumpkin Eater (Friday at 8:30PM, $1.25)

Locally, it was another packed weekend. WBZ-TV (Channel 4) aired another installment of Science Countdown 1965 on Saturday, February 20th from 2-3PM. WHYN-TV (Channel 40) aired a half-hour dance party from 2-2:30PM. WNHC-TV (Channel 8) broadcast highlights from the February 13th Yale Sports Weekend from 6:30-7:30PM.

And on Sunday, February 21st WTIC-TV (Channel 3) aired From the College Campus from 11:30AM-12PM, this time from Wesleyan University in Middletown, CT. WHDH-TV (Channel 5) aired another public affairs report from 12-1PM. The topic was “Where is Peaceable Lane?” about how Greater Boston was combating discriminatory housing practices. Both WBZ-TV and WNHC-TV aired live coverage of the National Indoor Singles Tennis Championship from 2-3:30PM. Jack Kramer and Jim McArthur called the action. WNAC-TV (Channel 7) premiered Repertory Theatre, a syndicated drama series hosted by Walter Kerr, at 2:30PM.

Finally, here’s an advertisement for news on WHYN-TV (Channel 40) out of Springfield, MA:

Advertisement for News and Weather on WHYN-TV (Channel 40)
Advertisement for News and Weather on WHYN-TV (Channel 40) – Copyright 1965 Triangle Publications, Inc.

Here are the episode descriptions for Dateline Boston, a local series broadcast live and in color Monday through Friday from 6-6:25PM on WHDH-TV (Channel 5):

Monday, February 22nd, 1965
Capt. Bob celebrates Washington’s Birthday with a drawing.

Tuesday, February 23rd, 1965
Beryl Robinson, Boston Public Library, suggests reading books for young children and baby sitters.

Wednesday, February 24th, 1965
“Frontiers of Science.” John Fitch explores a current scientific project in association with MIT.

Thursday, February 25th, 1965
“Heart Fund Sunday Preview.” A therapist, a doctor and a nurse discuss patients’ rehabilitation.

Friday, February 26th, 1965
“An Apple a Day.” Ways to safeguard the health of members of the local community are discussed.

That’s it for this week. Hit the comments with your thoughts.


7 Comments

  • Ken Douglas says:

    So, 1 good celeb out of 20 is good, huh? I sub to the What’s My Line? channel on YouTube, and from what i’ve seen, Mark Goodson and Bill Todman were definitely doin’ something right with that process. I’ve enjoyed the appearances of one Phyllis Newman. Until recently, i never came to appreciating her talents. I bet this criteria had been in place even when The Name’s the Same was popular.
    The TV Teletype was spot on about those cancellations, as well as two of the NBC shows. They premired during the 65-66 season and did well: I Spy ran until 1968 and made Cosby a big star, while The Dean Martin Show enjoyed a successful run into the early 70’s.
    Have i mentioned the fact that i used to collect editions of TV Guide? Had a good one going for a while. It began when we got the Kansas State edition by mistake instead of Kansas City. Among my favorite editions to get were:
    Montana
    Northern Colorado
    North Texas
    South Georgia
    Illinois/Wisconsin
    Los Angeles
    New Mexico
    Oregon State
    West Washington State
    Toledo/Lima
    Idaho
    Washington/Baltimore
    Central Pennsylvania
    Southeast Pennsylvania
    East Washington State
    Northern California
    Missouri
    North Carolina
    Nebraska
    Oklahoma
    New York Metro (sometimes)
    South Texas
    Louisiana
    New Hampshire
    Vermont
    I also liked the Rochester edition, it featured listings for that city as well as Buffalo, Syracuse and one Canadian channel.
    Nebraska was a fave because it also had listings for the stations in my hometown, Sioux Falls, SD, where i came into the world on 12/20/1963. Goodson and Todman were the mystery guest on WML that weekend.
    Kansas State became more of a favorite when they began listing the Topeka channels. I now wish they had included KTWU, that would have given that edition 3 PBS channels, along with Wichita’s KPTS channel 8 and KOOD channel 9 in Hays, not to mention listings for multiple stations on channels 8, 11 and 13 (with KOMC, now KSNK Oberlin/McCook, NE, KGLD-TV, now KSNG and KUPK in Garden City).
    The Boston edition i also liked for it carried listings for the Providence, RI and New Bedford, MA stations.
    LA gets a mention for it also had listings for stations in Santa Barbara (KEYT, channel 3), Santa Maria (KCOY-TV channel 12) and Palm Springs (KMIR channel 36 and KPLM-TV, now KESQ channel 42).
    Had the edition you use here still existed, i would have collected that one too.
    Sometime ago, i mentioned the analog sign-off of Hartford, CT’s WFSB channel 3, and it is classy. This be the link:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ztee7Q-jKGo
    I will look for the documentary “The Restless Sea”. Hopefully, someone posted it on YT. It seems like a great program to watch, judging by the ad.

  • paul kollmar says:

    — good to see you take in considerarion the value of Mr. Novak.====think again; it was THE FIRST EPISODIC series to cover teen age drug addiction**I don;t have the episode title in front of me here, but may post it later– Pressure to perform on exams} A theme timed well before the emergence of Timothy Leary( and his irresponsibility in corrupting youth) on the west coast===============Who would have believed that five years later there would be the emergence of Charles Manson??–California at its most dreaded;;

  • Phil says:

    Kathleen Nolan – a perfect case of speaking first and thinking second. The PT-73’s letter was a direct torpedo hit that sent her show to Davy Jones’ Locker, which is where it belonged. I watched the first ep. of ‘Broadside’ on Youtube last year and it was just plain awful. I tried parts of other episodes, but I couldn’t take it anymore. First, Joe Flynn was ten times better than Edward Andrews. Second, ‘Broadside’ had no equivalent of Tim Conway, none…forget about Dick Sargent, George Furth, and Arnold Stang.

  • Ray G says:

    I, for one, happened to like Broadside when first telecast. But then, I was 9 years old, so what did I know?

  • Bob says:

    Even Jim Garner and Fred Astaire have side jobs: Garner is an officer of the Silver Lake National Bank in Los Angeles and Astaire owns a chain of dancing schools.

    I’m shocked James Garner has any side jobs since he walked off “Maverick” at the height of it’s popularity. This could also explain why he had Universal tied up in court for over 10 years over his lost “Rockford” residuals.

  • Paul Duca says:

    James Garner had a very nice side job making feature films..

  • Joseph says:

    “Where The Action Is” became a series, but on ABC, and as a daily afternoon show (instead of a weekly prime-time series).

    It premiered as a summer replacement that June, airing at 2 P.M. Eastern time, and was supposed to go off the air in September.

    But the show became so popular (it supposedly was the first show that gave CBS’s “Password” a serious run in the ratings at that hour, especially among younger viewers) that it remained on the air until March, 1967, moving to 4:30 P.M. Eastern in the fall so that it would be seen after schools let out, allowing teenagers and children to continue to watch it.

Leave a Comment