Bookshelf: How Sweet It Was

Bookshelf is a monthly column examining printed matter relating to television. While I love watching TV, I also love reading about it, from tie-in novels to TV Guides, from vintage television magazines to old newspaper articles. Bookshelf is published on the second Thursday of each month.

How Sweet It Was: Television: A Pictorial Commentary
By Arthur Shulman and Roger Youman
First Published in 1966
Published by Shorecrest, Inc.
450 Pages

I bought a copy of this hefty tome at a used bookstore last year but put off reviewing it until now. Why? Because I wasn’t sure how to a review a book containing pictures and captions and nothing else. When I review a TV tie-in novel, I can talk about the story and whether the characters on the page match the characters on TV. Non-fiction books are also easy to review: is information useful, accurate, easy to find?

It wasn’t until I took the time to flip through How Sweet It Was that I realized it wouldn’t be difficult to review. The authors, both staff members at TV Guide, decided to shoehorn all of television into twelve categories. While that may seem like a lot, it’s really not. A lot of their choices about where to place certain TV shows make very little sense. It’s almost frustrating to try and figure out their reasoning. Comedies/sitcoms get their own chapter but dramas (excluding Westerns) are lumped in with dramatic anthologies. Sports are an afterthought, given a few pages in the final chapter about news and documentaries.

Here’s an excerpt from the introduction, in which Shulman and Youman explain purpose of the book:

Although this book is intended to be a comprehensive review of television during the past twenty years […] it is not meant to be just a scholarly history. The programs and people represented here were chosen not because they were “good” or “popular” or “successful,” but because each contributed, in some large or small way, to the progress of television. Theirs may not necessarily have been a beneficial contribution, just as the progress of the medium has not necessarily been in the direction of higher quality. Individually many of these pictures mean little, except to a few people; but considered cumulatively and in relation to each other, they constitute a panorama of the television scene since the last forties.

For better or for worse, in sickness and in health, this is what television has been during the past twenty years.

It’s hard to believe Shulman and Youman actually felt every single program included in How Sweet It Was contributed to “the progress of television” and they made some decisions about which TV shows and TV personalities to highlight.

Scan of the front cover of How Sweet It Was
Front Cover of How Sweet It Was – Copyright © 1966 Shorecrest, Inc.

The first chapter is called “A Bunch of Bananas” and focuses on comedians like Milton Berle, Sid Caeser, Red Skelton, Jack Benny, and Bob Hope who were among the earliest TV stars. Most of the comedians who tried to translate their humor and their acts to TV failed, according to the authors. Some of these comedians are given two or three pages filled with pictures while others get just one. It seems obvious the authors decided to give the popular and successful names more coverage. That said, it’s not clear why they devote three pages to Bob Hope but just one to Jack Benny. Martha Raye gets a full page while Phil Silvers has to make do with a single picture.

“Personalities Plus” is the title of the second chapter, which focuses on TV hosts and hostesses. Again, the bigger personalities get more pictures and text. Ed Sullivan is given three pages; Arthur Godfrey, Arlene Francis, and Garry More get two pages; and Faye Emerson gets one page. Yet Robert Q. Lewis, “host, guest, and panelist on dozens of television offerings” is only given a picture. TV shows like Candid Camera, The Hollywood Palace, and Today are given their own entries.

The third chapter, “The Sounds of Music,” is about singers. Kyle MacDonnell is included here. So are Liberace, Frank Sinatra, Bing Crosby, Perry Como, Dinah Shore, Rosemary Clooney, Ukulele Ike, Roberta Quinlan, Johnny Johnston, Martha Wright, Judy Garland, Dennis Day, Dean Martin, Tony Bennett, Nat King Cole, Jimmy Dean, and many others. TV shows like Your Hit Parade, The Arthur Murray Party, Hootenanny, Hullabaloo, and Shindig are also mentioned.

“Custom-Made Comedy” is the fourth chapter, devoted to sitcoms. The authors make their feelings about the quality of sitcoms very clear:

Thus a contemporary situation comedy consists of artificial characters in artificial situations being egged on by artificial laughter. From time to time, letters appear in magazines and newspapers complaining that some viewers resent maniacal laughter unaccompanied by anything even remotely funny. These complaints probably represent a minority viewpoint; presumably the cast, the producer, and most of the audience welcome the faked hysteria on the grounds that it provides reassurance that what is being perpetrated is indeed comedy.

An occasional rose blooms in the wasteland. A show appears, people with recognizable humans who do or say recognizably funny thigs. They are evidence that all is not irretrievably lost. It is still possible to create a situation comedy inhabited by humans, or reasonable facsimiles thereof, who can evoke genuine laughter. Though the industry relies on assembly lines, the craftsman still survives.

There is no mention of Mary Kay and Johnny, the very first TV sitcom in the United States. The chapter opens with I Love Lucy. But plenty of short-lived and obscure sitcoms are included, like Joe and Mabel, Peck’s Bad Girl, Norby, The Soldiers, Hank, My Living Doll, Doc Corkle, Glynis, Those Whiting Girls, and Camp Runamuck. Also found in this chapter is It’s a Man’s World, which I don’t consider a situation comedy.

Scan of the back cover of How Sweet It Was
Back Cover of How Sweet It Was – Copyright © 1966 Shorecrest, Inc.

The fifth chapter (“They Called Them Spectaculars”) discusses TV specials like “Irving Berlin’s Salute to America” (1951), “The Ford 50th Anniversary Show” (1953), “Satins and Spurs” (1954), “Peter Pan” (1955), “Cinderella” (1957), “Elizabeth Taylor in London” (1963), “The Beatles in America” (1964), and “My Name is Barbara” (1965).

“A Thousand and One Opening Nights” is the title of the sixth chapter, which starts out examining dramatic anthologies from the Golden Age of Television like Philco-Goodyear Television Playhouse, Studio One, Kraft Television Theatre, Camera Three, The U.S. Steel Hour, Hallmark Hall of Fame, Omnibus, and Playhouse 90. Halfway through the chapter, the focus shifts to weekly dramas like Bus Stop, Perry Mason, Slattery’s People, Janet Dean, Registered Nurse, Medic, and Ben Casey. Also, Peyton Place.

The seventh chapter, “Where the Action Is,” covers police, lawyers, spies, reporters, military men, and superheroes. “They Went Thataway,” the eighth chapter, is all about Westerns. The ninth chapter, “Next Question,” discusses prime time game shows. “While the Dishes Wait,” the tenth chapter, focuses on daytime television (game shows and soap operas). The eleventh chapter, “The Children’s Hour,” includes shows obviously aimed at kids like Howdy Doody, Captain Kangaroo, and Rocky Jones, Space Ranger but also family-friendly fare like Flipper, National Velvet, and Daktari.

The twelfth and final chapter, “The Real World,” examines news, documentaries, the Nixon-Kennedy debates, the Kennedy assassination, the Space Race, religious TV shows, art and culture, and sports.

To sum up, How Sweet It Was is an unusual book but if you can ignore the bizarre way the authors categorized certain TV shows, it’s not a bad one. The index helps; you can ignore the chapters entirely. There are 1,435 black-and-white photographs, many of them from short-lived and forgotten TV shows. Taken together, they do “constitute a panorama of the television scene since the late forties,” as the authors claim in their introduction.


This will be my last Bookshelf column for a while. Since 2008, I’ve reviewed more than 110 TV tie-in novels, comic books, magazines, and other books but I’ve finally run out. So, Bookshelf will be on hiatus until I can stockpile enough books to revive it.


7 Comments

  • Jon says:

    I have a copy of this book at home, a gift from my brother-in-law, IIRC. I’ve flipped through it a number of times but hope to give it another closer look soon. This is the first-published book that I have about tv, but it’s not the first I ever had or bought. That honor goes to TV BOOK, which I think I bought sometime in 1978. It had several articles about tv throughout and a running history of tv taking the bottom fourth or so of each page of main text. You may have reviewed this book in the past if you have it. Soon after this I bought books like THE COMPLETE DIRECTORY TO PRIME-TIME NETWORK TV SHOWS (1st ed) by Brooks & Marsh and TV GAME SHOWS by Maxene Fabe, and I’ve bought dozens of books like these since.

  • Eric Pleasant says:

    Actually this is the book that got me interested in old TV nostalgia when I bought it back in ’77. It was more of an introduction to old time TV and it simply started my interest on past entertainment both in the US and Great Britain.

  • David says:

    I was given a used copy of this book about five years ago.

  • paul kollmar says:

    the original issue of this book was at Womrath’s book chain in the metro nyc area before the NOSTALGIA BOOK CLUB even originated in new rochelle ; ny-*1973* ironically; the latter was a co – effort of LEONARD MALTIN when he first joined the film department at the Modern Museum in Manhattan–IT IS MOST VALUABLE for the source of rich detailed back and white photos that seem to have slipped between the cracks– the actual production companies did not KEEP THEM in any archive===**UCLA has an extensive archive/ especially with ABC tv-0 but is still only as active as those who contribute to it!=

  • Michael says:

    I have had a coy of this book for over 40 years. Before the internet, it was fun book to read with great photos. Today, it is a dust collector on my book shelf!
    But keeping books like this today, dates you. I would write more but the tubes in my Dumont TV, just warmed up.

  • James Shell says:

    I have a copy of this book. I first read it in high school, when I found it in the school library.

  • Patrick says:

    I received this book as a gift from my sister one Christmas long ago. I spent many pleasant hours reading it, and it sits in a special place in my library.

Leave a Comment